After a recent theater binge of live kid’s shows, I got the pleasure of seeing The Simon and Garfunkel Story at the Flynn Theater in Burlington, Vermont. It was one of the best shows based on a real musical act that I have seen, and I’ve seen a few. I have no problem watching cover bands, and I’m able to suspend disbelief to enjoy any performance as much as I would the real act. The Simon and Garfunkel Story is certainly not a cover band, cashing in on the successful duo. It was truly an amazing showcase of five incredibly talented performers. 

What’s The Simon and Garfunkel Story?

The Simon and Garfunkel Story is one part musical performance and one part live storytelling — all with a little help from a projector. But first, I should answer the question of many puzzled younger readers: “Who were Simon and Garfunkel?”

If 60s folk music isn’t your thing, Paul Simon and Art Garfunkel were a musical duo that grew up together and started making music in the late 50s. They saw increasing success through the late 60s, particularly with the music created for the hit film The Graduate and their 1970 album Bridge Over Troubled Water. Even though this record was the best selling album for three years in a row, the pair decided to part ways in the 70s, with Garfunkel taking on some acting roles and Simon branching off with a successful solo career.

A Powerful Performance

What makes this production stand out is how seamlessly it weaves together Simon and Garfunkel's personal story with their musical evolution. The story takes you on a journey through their friendship, their creative process, and the cultural backdrop that shaped their sound.

The performers—two actors portraying Simon and Garfunkel, plus a three-piece backing band—created an intimate atmosphere that feels more like sitting in on a private rehearsal than watching a theatrical production. The lead actors don’t try to impersonate the duo with phony mannerisms or costumes. Instead, they channel the essence of Simon and Garfunkel's musical partnership and capture the subtle harmonies and gentle tension that really defined their relationship.

More Than Just the Music

The storytelling element is where The Simon and Garfunkel Story truly shines. Between songs, the actors share anecdotes about the duo's journey—from their teenage years performing as Tom and Jerry (yes, that was their first stage name) to their meteoric rise and eventual split. They even mention Simon’s old flame Kathy Chitty, who inspired the song “America,” a classic track from their album Bookends, and of course, “Kathy’s Song.” These little details make you feel as if you’re listening to a narrated memoir. 

The projector screen behind the performers displays archival photos, album covers, and video footage that perfectly complement each story. When they performed "The Sound of Silence," the screen showed images of the turbulent 1960s that inspired the song. During "Mrs. Robinson," we saw clips from The Graduate, reminding us how their iconic soundtrack to the film 

These visual elements never felt gimmicky or overwhelming. They enhanced the storytelling without competing with the live performance, creating a multimedia experience that felt both nostalgic and fresh.

The Vocal Magic That Made It Memorable

Recreating Art Garfunkel's soaring harmonies is no easy feat, and the performer playing him absolutely nailed it. His voice had that ethereal quality that made the show’s encore, "Bridge Over Troubled Water," so hauntingly beautiful I nearly cried. Meanwhile, the actor portraying Paul Simon captured his distinctive vocals and impressive guitar work with accuracy and style.

The backing musicians deserve equal praise. The bass lines were crisp, the drumming was subtle yet driving, and the additional guitar work filled out the sound without overtaking the duo's delicate harmonies. During "Scarborough Fair," the interweaving melodies gave me goosebumps—a testament to both the original composition and the skill of these performers.

Why This Show Works for Everyone

The show serves as both a greatest hits concert and a music history lesson. Younger audience members get context for songs they might recognize without knowing the artists, while longtime fans discover new details about their musical heroes.

The pacing keeps everyone engaged. Upbeat numbers like "Cecilia" and "The 59th Street Bridge Song (Feelin' Groovy)" are balanced with introspective moments during "The Boxer" and "Old Friends." Each song serves the narrative, building toward the emotional climax of Simon & Garfunkel’s farewell performance.

You don't need to be an S&G superfan to appreciate this production. My husband came along as my date though he was only really familiar with the most popular songs. The skills of the vocalists alone were enough to keep us engaged, and the visuals and historical angle were just a bonus. We both agreed it was a great way to spend a Saturday night and I would even probably see it again if I have the chance. 

A Resonating Cultural Impact

What struck me most was how relevant Simon and Garfunkel's themes remain today. Their songs tackle concepts like social isolation, waning friendships, political upheaval, and the search for meaning and fulfillment — issues that are undoubtedly still valid today. "The Sound of Silence" speaks to a relatable disconnection, while "Bridge Over Troubled Water" offers the same hug-like comfort it did fifty years ago (and admittedly, nearly brought me to tears).

The Simon and Garfunkel Story tours internationally, so you should be able to catch it at a city near you if it hasn’t gotten there yet. Each venue adds its own character to the performance, but the intimate format works particularly well in smaller theaters like the Flynn, where every seat feels close to the action. There is a vibe similar to sitting by a fire with friends, that is really a testament to Simon and Garfunkel's ability to create both calm and community through their music.

A Perfect Intro to Timeless Music

If you're curious about Simon and Garfunkel or have just started listening to 60s folk, this show provides a perfect entry point. You'll leave with a deeper appreciation for their artistry and probably a few new favorite songs (though they definitely include all the hits!). For existing fans, it's a chance to hear beloved tracks performed live, which is more than most can say if you were born in the last couple decades. And unless you’re a superfan, you’ll probably learn a thing or two about the duo that you didn’t know.

The Simon and Garfunkel Story proves that tribute shows can be more than mimicry. When done with this level of care and talent, they become celebrations of musical legacy. I was reminded why these two men created such a defining moment in the history of American music, and it’s clear why certain songs continue to move us decades after they were written. Whether you're a theater regular, an S&G fan, or just in the mood for a relaxing night, this show deserves a spot on your must-see list.

Photo Credit: Michael Ochs Archives / Stringer via Getty Images